Tell me a story... about figuring out your own happiness
Maybe Once, Maybe Twice by Alison Rose Greenberg
Publication date: October 3, 2023
Date read: July 12, 2023
Maggie Vine’s life is going extra-medium. At 35 she’s pursuing her dreams of being a singer and being a mother―though neither is successfully panning out. So when Garrett Scholl―stifled hedge fund manager by day but electrifying aspiring rock singer by night―comes to her 35th birthday party with the intention to kiss Maggie senseless, it feels like one piece might click into place. Except he’s engaged to someone else, and Maggie knows she won’t fit into the cookie-cutter life he’s building for himself. Enter Asher Reyes. Her first boyfriend from summer camp, turned into heartthrob actor, he’s lived a successful yet private life ever since he got famous. When a career-changing opportunity is presented to Maggie after her reconnection with Asher, it feels like everything―music, love, family―will fall into place. But her past won’t let her move on without a fight.
Romance books seem to be pretty hit or miss for me, although even the worst ones mostly have at least some redeeming parts to them. I'm not saying that this book was one of the worst ones, but while there was a good amount that I did enjoy about this one, there was just also a lot that I did not like. I'm sure that there are some readers who love the trope of the protagonist who is just in love with the absolute worst person and makes bad decisions along the way, and if that's you it's okay! And in that case, you might love this book. But the main character pining after the horrible douchebag who treats her like crap just doesn't do it for me.
In addition, this book was just too long. It came in at 336 (which isn't horrible for a romance novel), but it really should have been cut down to about 250 pages. There is a drawn out reveal of a past mistake that was compelling at first, but then just became annoying.
And I'm not saying the book is irredeemable, because most of the plot actually flows pretty well and is interesting. I liked the romance between Maggie and her childhood boyfriend, Asher. I also, at first, was not on board with the way that the book was ending, but it turned in a way that I ended up liking. I think that Maggie had some serious soul-searching to do after all of her life choices, and I liked the way it played out.
Overall, an okay romance, but there were too many bad decisions and drawn-out plot points for my taste. Fans of the trope of the girl falling for the wrong guy and having to find herself might like this one more than I did, but it really just wasn't for me.
Content warning: suicide, absent parent, consensual sex between teenagers, sexual assault
Rating: (a weak) 3/5 stars
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an advanced copy of this book