The Woman in the Library

 Tell me a story... about a murder among new friends

The Woman in the Library by Sulari Gentill

Publication date: June 7, 2022

Date read: July 17, 2022

The ornate reading room at the Boston Public Library is quiet, until the silence is shattered by a woman’s terrified scream. While they wait for the all-clear from security, four strangers sitting at the same table pass the time in conversation and a friendship is struck. Each person at that table has their own reason for being in the reading room that morning - it just so happens that one of them is murder. 

This book is kind of two books in one. First, there is the murder mystery. Second, there is the writing of the murder mystery. Between chapters, we are shown letters from a fan of the author who she is using as a proofreader and resource (since the reader lives in the Boston area and the author does not). Confusing? At first. But after a few chapters, I got used to the format and ended up really enjoying the choice to write it this way. 

There are a lot of unlikable characters in this book. I definitely found myself getting angry about comments or choices that characters made, only to realize later that the comment was not a mistake by the author, but rather foreshadowing about the motives of a character. So give the author a little more benefit of the doubt than I did. 

Murder mysteries are hard to review, because I really don’t want to give away any plot points. So I’ll speak only in general terms about the book itself, rather than the plot. 

I thought that the book was written pretty well, if not perfectly. There were some obvious cliches and some romantic relationships that had me rolling my eyes a bit. But it was a decent murder mystery and I feel that the reveal holds up and doesn’t leave any unanswered questions that I can recall. So while I didn’t love the characters and relationships as much as I wish I had, I enjoyed the mystery enough that I would recommend this one. 

Overall, it’s a fun murder mystery with a little added twist of a fourth wall break (the mystery being shown to be a book that an author was writing). Enjoyable, as long as you don’t take it all too seriously. 

Rating: 3.5/5 stars

Trigger warning: murder, pandemic, physical assault, mentions of sexual assault, mentions of Australian wildfires, racism, stalking

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an advanced copy of this book.